Our Flavours
Showing all 69 results
-
Sur-pies!
$25.00 – $30.00Available to order
-
Apple and Gooseberry Pie
$27.50 – $33.50This pie is not available (ingredients not available)
-
Apple and Ooray (Davidson Plum) Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Apple Pie
$27.50 – $33.50Available to order
-
Apple Strudel Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Apricot Pie
$37.50 – $43.50Available to order
-
Banana Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Banbury Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Banoffi Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Bavarian Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Biscoff Pie
$37.50 – $40.00Available to order
-
Bluebarb Pie
$37.50 – $43.50Available to order
-
Blueberry Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Boysenberry Pie
$37.50 – $43.50Available to order
-
Buttermilk Pie
$27.50 – $32.50Available to order
-
Cherry Pie
$32.50 – $38.50This pie is not available (ingredients not available)
-
Chess Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Chocolate Chess Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Chocolate Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Chocolate Fudge Pie (Salicylate Sensitivity Friendly)
$27.50 – $32.50Available to order
-
Chocolate Pecan Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Chocolate Pumpkin Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Coconut Chai Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Coconut Cream Pie
$27.50 – $32.50Available to order
-
Eggnog Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Gulalung (Finger Lime) Pie
$40.00 – $45.00Available to order
-
Key Lime Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Lamington Pie
$27.50Available to order
-
Lemon Chess Pie
$27.50 – $32.50Available to order
-
Lemon Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Lemon Myrtle Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Macadamia Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Maple Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
May Day Pie
$37.50 – $45.00Available to order
-
Mexican Chocolate Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Mississippi Mud Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Neapolitan Cream Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Nutty Fudge Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Oatmeal Pie
$37.50Available to order
-
Peach Cobbler Pie
$32.50Available to order
-
Peach Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Peanut Butter Pie
$27.50 – $32.50Available to order
-
Pear Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Pear and Blueberry Pie
$27.50 – $33.50Available to order
-
Pear and Lilly Pilly Pie
$37.50 – $43.50Available to order
-
Pear and Raspberry Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Pear and Urti (Quandong) Pie
$37.50 – $43.50Available to order
-
Pecan Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Pepperberry, Raspberry and Dark Chocolate Pie
$37.50 – $42.50Available to order
-
Plum Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Pumpkin Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Raspberry Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Red Fruit Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Salted Honey Pie
$32.50Available to order
-
Shoofly Pie
$27.50Available to order
-
Sour Morello Cherry Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Spiced Pear and Walnut Pie
$27.50 – $33.50Available to order
-
Strawberry and Rhubarb Pie
$37.50 – $43.50Available to order
-
Strawberry Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Sugar Cream Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Sweet Potato Pie
$32.50 – $37.50Available to order
-
Urti (Quandong) Pie
$40.00 – $46.00Available to order
-
Vermont Maple and Apple Pie
$32.50 – $38.50Available to order
-
Wet-bottomed Shoofly Pie
$27.50Available to order
-
Pastry – Signature All-Butter Crust
$5.50 – $23.50Available to order
-
Pastry – Vegan Friendly Crust
$5.50 – $23.50Available to order
-
Pastry – Very Low Gluten Crust
$7.00 – $11.00Available to order
-
9″ Pie Tin
$0.80Available now
-
Gift Voucher
$30.00 – $101.20Available now
Our Crusts:
Signature All-Butter Crust
Flaky and butteryOur Signature All-Butter Crust is flaky and buttery, yet it has the structure necessary to support our pie fillings.
- This crust contains just these six ingredients:
- Butter
- Red Wine Vinegar
- Water
- Flour
- Salt
- White Sugar
Graham Cracker Crust
Crumbly and biscuit-basedOur Graham Cracker Crust is crumbly and tasty. We make the Graham Crackers from scratch!
- This crust contains the following ingredients:
- Wholemeal Flour
- Butter
- Cream
- Treacle
- Dark Brown Sugar
- White Sugar
- Wheat Flour
- Skim Milk Powder
- Milk
- Salt
- Baking Powder
- Vanilla Extract
- Bicarb Soda
- Cinnamon
Note: This crust is only available with no-cook or short-cook fillings (cream pies mainly)
Vegan Coconut Oil Crust
Plant-based and coconuttyOur plant-based vegan pie crust uses coconut oil instead of butter. It is flaky, delicious and has a light coconut flavour.
- This crust contains just these six ingredients:
- Coconut Oil
- Red Wine Vinegar
- Water
- Flour
- Salt
- White Sugar
Note: If the vegan crust is selected, the ingredients in the pie will be plant-based as well. This will be impossible for some pies.
- Click here to view the pies that can be made Vegan Friendly.
Very Low Gluten Crust
Flaky and butteryOur very low gluten pie crust is a delicious, flaky and strong pie crust that is butter and sour cream-based. It actually does not contain any gluten; we just don’t have the certification to claim ‘Gluten Free’ status.
- This crust contains these ingredients:
- Butter
- Maize Starch
- Modified Starch (1422)
- Rice Flour
- Soy Flour
- Xanthan Gum
- Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate (450)
- Sodium Bicarbonate (500]
- Salt
- White Sugar
- Sour Cream
- Water
Note: If the very low gluten crust is selected, no gluten will be added to the pie filling either. This will be impossible for some pies.
- Click here to view the pies that can be made Very Low Gluten.
Other Crusts
Some pies have another crust option which complements that specific flavour.- The following pies have extra crust options:
- Biscoff Pie – Biscoff Crust
- Chocolate Fudge Pie – Lard Crust (Salicylate Sensitivity Friendly)
- Gulalung (Finger Lime) Pie – Wattleseed Graham Crust
- Mississippi Mud Pie – Chocolate Pecan Graham CrustÂ
- Neapolitan Cream Pie – Waffle Cone Crust
Note: For a list of ingredients for these crusts, please see the relevant pie flavour page.
Future Pie Ideas:
In my travels around the US, I picked up a pile of cookbooks full of exciting pie recipes. There are not your Jamie Oliver or Nigella Lawson cookbooks – they are good old-fashioned local recipes used by real people in real places. We are excited to bake and share with you some of the nuggets of gold from these books in the coming days. Some of the ideas for flavours which we are looking forward to trying are listed below.
Bananas Foster Pie
Black Bottom Pie
Brown Sugar Pie
Butterscotch Pie
Caramel-Banana Cream Pie
Carolina Bread Pie
Chocolate Mint Pie
Chocolate Pie
Cornmeal Pie
Cranberry Chess Pies
Cranberry Nut Pie
Davidson Plum Cream Pie
Espresso Cream Pie
Funeral Pie
Gooey Butter Cake Pie
Japanese Fruit Pie
Jeff Davis Pie
Lemon Chiffon Pie
Lemon Curd Pie
Million Dollar Pie
Molasses Pie
Mud Hen Pie
Oh So Good Pie
Old Fashioned Egg Pie
Orange Cream Pie
Ozark Pie
Pumpkin Spice Latte Pie
Raisin Pie
Rum Pie
S’mores Pie
Southern Mud Pie
Sweet Corn Custard
Vinegar Chess Pie